ONUW #3

124

Comments

  • MalionMalion RabbleRouser,
    Mittens wrote: »
    UNOFFICIAL (but confident it's correct)

    Darkus (1) - tier
    Mittens (1) - butternuts
    Nav (0) - tier

    This is right!

    Also! I forgot to implement this rule last time but if you don't vote that is a self-vote.

    So get those votes in!
  • MittensMittens RabbleRouser,
    It's assumed from the get go that someone is lying, right?
  • MittensMittens RabbleRouser,
    And ya the site is dying a horrible death
  • TierTier Offishal,
    I think bnuts is the one lying now that DS stood by his claim that darkus is town. Only other thing I could see is nav lying about being seer as tanner, but that doesn't really make sense cause he's not actively pushing to be lynched at all.

    ##lynch @Butternuts
  • MittensMittens RabbleRouser,
    I'm lynching DS until he tells us what his role was.

    #lynch @DS
  • TierTier Offishal,
    Mittens wrote: »
    I'm lynching DS until he tells us what his role was.

    #lynch @DS

    I'm 90% sure it was hunter.
    Mittens
  • thenavneetthenavneet RabbleRouser
    Can you just come out and say that you were Hunter, DS.

    If you were Insomniac, you would know your role got switched and thus you would know if Tier is being honest.

    The only thing we need to figure out is whether Tier as Werewolf saw Card #2, saw Troublemaker and knew he could
  • #lynch bunts
  • thenavneetthenavneet RabbleRouser
    I thought I already voted??

    #lynch @Butternuts
  • thenavneetthenavneet RabbleRouser
    thenavneet wrote: »
    Can you just come out and say that you were Hunter, DS.

    If you were Insomniac, you would know your role got switched and thus you would know if Tier is being honest.

    The only thing we need to figure out is whether Tier as Werewolf saw Card #2, saw Troublemaker and knew he could

    ... and knew he could lie about being Troublemaker.

    But yeah that is more of a stretch than Bnuts just being bad.
  • TierTier Offishal,
    thenavneet wrote: »
    Can you just come out and say that you were Hunter, DS.

    If you were Insomniac, you would know your role got switched and thus you would know if Tier is being honest.

    The only thing we need to figure out is whether Tier as Werewolf saw Card #2, saw Troublemaker and knew he could

    No Insomniac in this game.

    We also need to make sure you aren't ww, saw seer and claimed to see ww/tanner under the cards cause you knew the tanner wouldn't cc you.
  • MalionMalion RabbleRouser,
    DS (1) - mittens
    Mittens (1) - butternuts
    Butternuts (3) - tier, Darkus, nav
  • MittensMittens RabbleRouser,
    thenavneet wrote: »
    Can you just come out and say that you were Hunter, DS.

    Yes, please!
  • MittensMittens RabbleRouser,
    So basically this comes down to a ranking system of sorts on what's unlikely to have happened.

  • MittensMittens RabbleRouser,
    At this point I think it's unlikely that DS was warewolf and slow played this long, and it's also unlikely that Darkus lied about being villager, so DS and Darkus are both clean.

    It's also pretty unlikely that Nav lied about being seer, and assuming the tanner wouldn't counter? I guess without playing before I don't know what I would do in that situation if I was the tanner, but seems kind of like a toss up that that player would just fuck with the warewolf at that point lol.

    Tier was quick on the trigger with his info, so that also seems unlikely that he lied - but maybe that's the perfect play?

    I can't really analyze myself without some serious wifom, so that's up to you guys.

    So it comes down to Tier and bnuts for me - leaning heavily towards bnuts. Unless DS comes in as a wildcard and claims he was something other than Hunter
  • DSDS RabbleRouser
    Site died earlier but i saved this post and I meant to post it earlier but the site was dead and then i headed to work



    Villager (2)
    -Bnuts/Darkus

    Hunter
    -DS

    Seer
    -Nav

    Troublemaker
    -Tier
    Drunk
    -Mittens
    Werewolf (2)
    -only one if you believe nav
    Tanner


    someone has got to be lying about their role
    dEoVuVB_d.jpg?maxwidth=280&shape=thumb&fidelity=high

    Ah, you’ve been listening to cactus.
  • DSDS RabbleRouser
    its either bnuts or nav
    dEoVuVB_d.jpg?maxwidth=280&shape=thumb&fidelity=high

    Ah, you’ve been listening to cactus.
  • MittensMittens RabbleRouser,
    Thanks for sharing DS

    I think it’s far more likely to be bnuts lying.

    #lynch @Butternuts
  • DSDS RabbleRouser
    If it’s nav he deserves to win

    #lynch @bnuts
    dEoVuVB_d.jpg?maxwidth=280&shape=thumb&fidelity=high

    Ah, you’ve been listening to cactus.
  • thenavneetthenavneet RabbleRouser
    It still could be Tier but Bnuts is way more likely
  • ButternutsButternuts RabbleRouser,
    gg
  • DSDS RabbleRouser
    If it’s darkus I’m gonna hit
    dEoVuVB_d.jpg?maxwidth=280&shape=thumb&fidelity=high

    Ah, you’ve been listening to cactus.
  • ButternutsButternuts RabbleRouser,
    its 50/50
    im the drunk, im werewolf or tanner

    wasnt gonna get you to lynch anyone but mittens who is the wolf so took the 50/50
  • MalionMalion RabbleRouser,

    Mittens (1) - butternuts
    Butternuts (5) - tier, Darkus, nav, mittens, ds

    Butternuts is lynched!

    His role was... Drunk! Keyword was. He forgot his role and got a new one which was...

    f1KekuY.png

    Werewolves lose and town wins!
  • ButternutsButternuts RabbleRouser,
    ffffffff
  • TierTier Offishal,
    yay. who was other ww?
  • TierTier Offishal,
    I assume mittens?
  • MalionMalion RabbleRouser,
    Mittens was the other werewolf
  • TierTier Offishal,
    why didnt you contest him bnuts?
  • ButternutsButternuts RabbleRouser,
    Tier wrote: »
    why didnt you contest him bnuts?

    Getting mittens lynched was a loss for me, either I’m wolf with him and we lose or I’m tanner and I lose.
    he claimed drunk and said he picked 2, I picked 3 so I knew I was wolf or tanner.
    The 50% chance of tanner meant whatever I did I was always 50% to win, and I thought the best way to win was to win as tanner so went with that
Sign In or Register to comment.